Disney's Old Key West Resort vs Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

Disney's Old Key West Resort

Experience the romance of the Florida Keys at this tranquil community of Conch Flats—a sprawling island hamlet with shimmering waterways, swaying palm trees and manicured golf-course fairways. Delight in sun-soaked pools, casual dining and such amenities as fully equipped kitchens or kitchenettes.

Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

The newer tower within the Swan and Dolphin complex, positioned near Crescent Lake and marketed as a more boutique-style Marriott option.

Disney's Old Key West Resort

Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

Disney's Old Key West Resort

• Boat

  Disney Springs

• Bus

  Magic Kingdom Park, EPCOT, Disney's Hollywood Studios, Disney's Animal Kingdom Theme Park, Disney Springs

Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

• Walk

  EPCOT, Disney's Hollywood Studios

• Boat

  EPCOT, Disney's Hollywood Studios

• Bus

  Magic Kingdom Park, Disney's Animal Kingdom Theme Park, Disney Springs

Disney's Old Key West Resort

• Largest room sizes of any Disney Vacation Club resort
• Relaxed, laid-back Key West atmosphere ideal for adults
• Full kitchen in villa rooms great for longer stays
• Quieter and less crowded than other Disney resorts
• Close to Disney Springs with boat transportation available

Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

• Newest and most modern of the Swan and Dolphin complex
• Spacious tower rooms with contemporary design and updated amenities
• Same Crescent Lake location with walking access to EPCOT
• Marriott Bonvoy points redemption available
• Quieter and more upscale feel than the larger Swan and Dolphin hotels

Disney's Old Key West Resort

• Very spread-out resort, some villa clusters feel isolated
• Primarily a DVC property, harder to book on cash reservations
• Bus-only transportation to theme parks; boat only goes to Disney Springs
• Limited table service dining compared to other Deluxe resorts
• Lower-energy atmosphere may not feel as immersive for park-focused guests

Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

• No Disney on-site perks such as Early Entry or booking advantages
• High resort fees on top of nightly rate increase true cost
• Smaller pool exclusive to Swan Reserve guests, main pools are at Swan/Dolphin
• Limited dining within the Swan Reserve itself
• No direct transportation to Magic Kingdom or Animal Kingdom

Disney's Old Key West Resort

• Good's Food to Go

  Quick Service

  American

  breakfast

  View menu

• Gurgling Suitcase

  Quick Service

  American

  snack

  View menu

• Olivia's Cafe

  Table Service

  American

  breakfast · lunch · dinner

  View menu

• Olivia's Cafe To Go

  Quick Service

  American

  lunch · dinner

  View menu

• Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks

  Quick Service

  American

  lunch

  View menu

Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

• Amare

  Table Service

  Mediterranean

  lunch · dinner

  View menu

• Grounds

  Table Service

  Bakery, American, Quick Service - Coffee

  snack

  View menu

• Stir

  Table Service

  American

  dinner

  View menu

• Tangerine

  Table Service

  American

  dinner

  View menu

Disney's Old Key West Resort

• How is Old Key West? : r/WaltDisneyWorld
  r/WaltDisneyWorld
• Old Key West : r/WaltDisneyWorld
  r/WaltDisneyWorld
• Old Key West/ Saratoga Springs: are they *honestly* okay?
  r/WaltDisneyWorld
• Solo staying at Old Key West : r/WaltDisneyWorld
  r/WaltDisneyWorld

Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

• Swan & Dolphin appreciation : r/WaltDisneyWorld
  r/WaltDisneyWorld
• Swan or Swan Reserve? : r/WaltDisneyWorld
  r/WaltDisneyWorld
• Swan Reserve pros and cons : r/WaltDisneyWorld
  r/WaltDisneyWorld
• Thoughts on the Swan Reserve? : r/WaltDisneyWorld
  r/WaltDisneyWorld
• Walt Disney World Swan Reserve and ADR/LL
  r/WaltDisneyWorld

Disney's Old Key West Resort

• 
  Should YOU Stay at Disney's Old Key West Resort?

  DFBGuide

Walt Disney World Swan Reserve

• 
  Disney Swan, Dolphin & Swan Reserve FULL Resort Tours

  DFBGuide