Disney's Old Key West Resort vs Walt Disney World Swan
Photo: Disney's Old Key West Resort
Photo: Walt Disney World Swan
At a Glance
| Old Key West | Walt Disney World Swan | |
|---|---|---|
| Tier | Deluxe | Deluxe |
| Area | Disney Springs Resort Area | Epcot Resort Area |
| Transportation | Boat, Bus | Walk, Boat, Bus |
| Table-Service Dining | 1 restaurant | 5 restaurants |
| Quick-Service Dining | 4 locations | 3 locations |
| Pool Amenities | Pool, Quiet Pool | Pool, Water Slide |
| Extended Evening Hours | Yes | Yes |
| Top Highlight | Largest room sizes of any Disney Vacation Club resort | Same Crescent Lake location and EPCOT walking distance as the Dolphin |
Tier
Old Key West
DeluxeWalt Disney World Swan
DeluxeArea
Old Key West
Disney Springs Resort AreaWalt Disney World Swan
Epcot Resort AreaTransportation
Old Key West
Boat, BusWalt Disney World Swan
Walk, Boat, BusTable-Service Dining
Old Key West
1 restaurantWalt Disney World Swan
5 restaurantsQuick-Service Dining
Old Key West
4 locationsWalt Disney World Swan
3 locationsPool Amenities
Old Key West
Pool, Quiet PoolWalt Disney World Swan
Pool, Water SlideExtended Evening Hours
Old Key West
YesWalt Disney World Swan
YesTop Highlight
Old Key West
Largest room sizes of any Disney Vacation Club resortWalt Disney World Swan
Same Crescent Lake location and EPCOT walking distance as the DolphinOverview
Disney's Old Key West Resort
Experience the romance of the Florida Keys at this tranquil community of Conch Flats—a sprawling island hamlet with shimmering waterways, swaying palm trees and manicured golf-course fairways. Delight in sun-soaked pools, casual dining and such amenities as fully equipped kitchens or kitchenettes.
Walt Disney World Swan
A Marriott-operated on-property resort between Epcot and Hollywood Studios, with walking and boat access to both parks.
Amenities
Disney's Old Key West Resort
Recreation
- Pool
- Quiet Pool
- Tennis Courts
- Playground
- Electric Eel Game Room
- Jogging Trail
- Marina
- Fishing excursions
Wellness
- discover a dry sauna at the base of a lighthouse
- Fitness Center
- R.E.S.T. Health Club
Other
- Laundry Facilities
Walt Disney World Swan
Recreation
- Pool
- Water Slide
- Volleyball
- Tennis Courts
- Jogging Trail
- Arcade
- Playground
- Camp Dolphin for children ages 5-12 from 4PM to 11PM with themed activities, video games, arts and crafts
- Swan watercraft rentals on the white sand beach; Boat Rental in Activities
Wellness
- Fitness Center
- Spa
Other
- Child Care
- Boat launch courtyard between Swan and Dolphin for Friendship launches
- Disney Cabanas store at Swan; Resort Essentials boutique at Dolphin
Transportation
Disney's Old Key West Resort
-
Boat
Disney Springs
-
Bus
Magic Kingdom Park, EPCOT, Disney's Hollywood Studios, Disney's Animal Kingdom Theme Park, Disney Springs
Walt Disney World Swan
-
Walk
EPCOT, Disney's Hollywood Studios
-
Boat
EPCOT, Disney's Hollywood Studios
-
Bus
Magic Kingdom Park, Disney's Animal Kingdom Theme Park, Disney Springs
Pros
Disney's Old Key West Resort
- Largest room sizes of any Disney Vacation Club resort
- Relaxed, laid-back Key West atmosphere ideal for adults
- Full kitchen in villa rooms great for longer stays
- Quieter and less crowded than other Disney resorts
- Close to Disney Springs with boat transportation available
Walt Disney World Swan
- Same Crescent Lake location and EPCOT walking distance as the Dolphin
- Marriott Bonvoy points eligible for stays and redemptions
- Access to Dolphin's extensive dining and amenities via shared complex
- Swan Reserve and Swan combined offer over 2,000 rooms in the complex
- Competitively priced relative to Disney-owned Deluxe resorts nearby
Cons
Disney's Old Key West Resort
- Very spread-out resort, some villa clusters feel isolated
- Primarily a DVC property, harder to book on cash reservations
- Bus-only transportation to theme parks; boat only goes to Disney Springs
- Limited table service dining compared to other Deluxe resorts
- Lower-energy atmosphere may not feel as immersive for park-focused guests
Walt Disney World Swan
- No Disney on-site Early Entry or advance Lightning Lane booking
- Resort fees and parking fees add significantly to the nightly rate
- Shared amenities with Dolphin mean crowded pools during peak times
- Design is less Disney-immersive than Disney-owned resorts
- Limited transportation compared to monorail or Skyliner resorts
On-Site Dining
Disney's Old Key West Resort
-
Good's Food to Go
Quick ServiceAmerican
breakfast
View menu -
Gurgling Suitcase
Quick ServiceAmerican
snack
View menu -
Olivia's Cafe
Table ServiceAmerican
breakfast · lunch · dinner
View menu -
Olivia's Cafe To Go
Quick ServiceAmerican
lunch · dinner
View menu -
Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks
Quick ServiceAmerican
lunch
View menu
Walt Disney World Swan
-
Chill
Table ServiceAmerican
dinner
View menu -
Garden Grove
Table ServiceAmerican
breakfast
View menu -
Il Mulino
Table ServiceItalian
lunch · dinner
View menu -
Il Mulino Lounge
Quick ServiceAmerican
snack
View menu -
Java
Quick ServiceQuick Service - Coffee
snack
View menu -
Kimonos
Table ServiceAsian, Japanese, Sushi
dinner · snack
View menu -
Kimonos Lounge
Quick ServiceAsian, Japanese, Sushi
snack
View menu -
Splash Pool Bar and Grill
Table ServiceAmerican
snack
View menu
Community Discussions
Disney's Old Key West Resort
- How is Old Key West? : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Old Key West : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Old Key West/ Saratoga Springs: are they *honestly* okay? r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Solo staying at Old Key West : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
Walt Disney World Swan
- Anyone stay at the Walt Disney swan hotel? Thoughts or ... r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Some love for the Swan hotel - a great option for a Disney trip r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Walt Disney World Swan hotel review : r/DisneyWorld r/DisneyWorld
Videos
Disney's Old Key West Resort
Ready to plan your trip?
Start building your Disney World itinerary with our step-by-step planner. Choose dates, parks, and dining — all in one place.
Get Me Started