Disney's All-Star Movies Resort vs Disney's Old Key West Resort
Photo: Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
Photo: Disney's Old Key West Resort
At a Glance
| All-Star Movies | Old Key West | |
|---|---|---|
| Tier | Value | Deluxe |
| Area | Animal Kingdom Resort Area | Disney Springs Resort Area |
| Transportation | Bus | Boat, Bus |
| Table-Service Dining | None | 1 restaurant |
| Quick-Service Dining | 2 locations | 4 locations |
| Pool Amenities | Pool | Pool, Quiet Pool |
| Extended Evening Hours | No | Yes |
| Top Highlight | Lowest-cost way to stay on Disney property | Largest room sizes of any Disney Vacation Club resort |
Tier
All-Star Movies
ValueOld Key West
DeluxeArea
All-Star Movies
Animal Kingdom Resort AreaOld Key West
Disney Springs Resort AreaTransportation
All-Star Movies
BusOld Key West
Boat, BusTable-Service Dining
All-Star Movies
NoneOld Key West
1 restaurantQuick-Service Dining
All-Star Movies
2 locationsOld Key West
4 locationsPool Amenities
All-Star Movies
PoolOld Key West
Pool, Quiet PoolExtended Evening Hours
All-Star Movies
NoOld Key West
YesTop Highlight
All-Star Movies
Lowest-cost way to stay on Disney propertyOld Key West
Largest room sizes of any Disney Vacation Club resortOverview
Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
A value resort built around classic Disney and Pixar film iconography, with themed sections such as Toy Story, Fantasia, and 101 Dalmatians.
Disney's Old Key West Resort
Experience the romance of the Florida Keys at this tranquil community of Conch Flats—a sprawling island hamlet with shimmering waterways, swaying palm trees and manicured golf-course fairways. Delight in sun-soaked pools, casual dining and such amenities as fully equipped kitchens or kitchenettes.
Amenities
Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
Recreation
- Pool
- movies under the stars
- Playground
- Arcade
- Running Trail
Other
- Gift Shop
Disney's Old Key West Resort
Recreation
- Pool
- Quiet Pool
- Tennis Courts
- Playground
- Electric Eel Game Room
- Jogging Trail
- Marina
- Fishing excursions
Wellness
- discover a dry sauna at the base of a lighthouse
- Fitness Center
- R.E.S.T. Health Club
Other
- Laundry Facilities
Transportation
Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
-
Bus
Magic Kingdom Park, EPCOT, Disney's Hollywood Studios, Disney's Animal Kingdom Theme Park, Disney Springs
Disney's Old Key West Resort
-
Boat
Disney Springs
-
Bus
Magic Kingdom Park, EPCOT, Disney's Hollywood Studios, Disney's Animal Kingdom Theme Park, Disney Springs
Pros
Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
- Lowest-cost way to stay on Disney property
- Fun Toy Story and Fantasia themed areas kids love
- Free Disney bus transportation included
- On-site perks like Early Entry and advance Lightning Lane booking
- Fantasia pool is one of the best themed pools at the All Stars
Disney's Old Key West Resort
- Largest room sizes of any Disney Vacation Club resort
- Relaxed, laid-back Key West atmosphere ideal for adults
- Full kitchen in villa rooms great for longer stays
- Quieter and less crowded than other Disney resorts
- Close to Disney Springs with boat transportation available
Cons
Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
- Smallest and most basic rooms at Walt Disney World (260 sq ft)
- Bus service is frequently slow and unreliable
- Some themed sections feel dated (Mighty Ducks, Herbie)
- Food court quality is below other Value Resort food courts
- Frequently hosts large school and youth sports groups
Disney's Old Key West Resort
- Very spread-out resort, some villa clusters feel isolated
- Primarily a DVC property, harder to book on cash reservations
- Bus-only transportation to theme parks; boat only goes to Disney Springs
- Limited table service dining compared to other Deluxe resorts
- Lower-energy atmosphere may not feel as immersive for park-focused guests
On-Site Dining
Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
Disney's Old Key West Resort
-
Good's Food to Go
Quick ServiceAmerican
breakfast
View menu -
Gurgling Suitcase
Quick ServiceAmerican
snack
View menu -
Olivia's Cafe
Table ServiceAmerican
breakfast · lunch · dinner
View menu -
Olivia's Cafe To Go
Quick ServiceAmerican
lunch · dinner
View menu -
Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks
Quick ServiceAmerican
lunch
View menu
Community Discussions
Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
- All star Movies : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
- All star movies, music, or sports? : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Art of animation or all star movies : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Is All-Star Movies really that much more popular than ... r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Pop Century vs. All-Star Movies : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
Disney's Old Key West Resort
- How is Old Key West? : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Old Key West : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Old Key West/ Saratoga Springs: are they *honestly* okay? r/WaltDisneyWorld
- Solo staying at Old Key West : r/WaltDisneyWorld r/WaltDisneyWorld
Videos
Disney's All-Star Movies Resort
Disney's Old Key West Resort
Ready to plan your trip?
Start building your Disney World itinerary with our step-by-step planner. Choose dates, parks, and dining — all in one place.
Get Me Started